tutorialbeginnerMinecraft 26.3

Minecraft fishing guide: treasure odds, Lure vs Luck of the Sea and open water

Fishing is the easiest source of name tags, saddles and Mending-capable enchanted books, but only in open water. Here are the real catch odds, what Lure and Luck of the Sea actually change, the open water rule that gates all treasure, and how rain speeds you up.

David Riperson5 min read

Fishing looks like a calm side activity, but it is one of the best treasure sources in the game. A rod can pull up name tags, saddles, nautilus shells and high-level enchanted books, with no fighting at all. The catch: treasure only comes from open water, and most people fish in spots that quietly turn it off.

Quick answers

  • Odds with a plain rod: 85% fish, 10% junk, 5% treasure.
  • With Luck of the Sea III: treasure rises to about 11.3%, junk drops to about 4.1%.
  • Lure: makes bites come faster: each level cuts 5 seconds off the wait.
  • Open water: treasure needs a 5 by 4 by 5 area of plain water (or air) around the bobber. No open water, no treasure.
  • Rain: fishing in the rain under open sky is about 20% faster.

Fishing catches: cod, salmon, pufferfish and tropical fish, plus treasure like enchanted books, bows, name tags, saddles and nautilus shells Image: SyntaxMine, made from Minecraft's own textures.

What you can catch

Fish (85%)

Fish Share of fish
Raw cod 60%
Raw salmon 25%
Pufferfish 13%
Tropical fish 2%

Cook cod and salmon for decent food (our food guide ranks them). Pufferfish are poisonous to eat but make water breathing potions.

Treasure (5%, more with Luck of the Sea)

Six items, equally likely:

  • Enchanted book
  • Enchanted bow
  • Enchanted fishing rod
  • Name tag
  • Nautilus shell
  • Saddle

Treasure books, bows and rods are enchanted as if at level 22 to 30, and they can roll treasure enchantments like Mending. That makes fishing one of the few renewable ways to get Mending without a librarian. The bows and rods come back heavily damaged, so Mending on them is the real prize.

Junk (10%)

Lily pads, bones, bowls, leather, leather boots, rotten flesh, tripwire hooks, water bottles, sticks, string, a damaged rod, and rarely an ink sac. In jungles you can also pull up bamboo.

Lure vs Luck of the Sea

These two do different jobs and you want both.

Lure (max III) makes fish bite sooner. The base wait for a bite is 5 to 30 seconds, and each Lure level takes 5 seconds off both ends:

Lure Wait for a bite
None 5 to 30 s
I 0 to 25 s
II about 0 to 20 s
III about 0 to 15 s

Luck of the Sea (max III) changes what you catch:

Luck of the Sea Fish Treasure Junk
None 85% 5% 10%
I 84.9% 7.1% 8.1%
II 84.7% 9.2% 6.1%
III 84.5% 11.3% 4.1%

Lure gives you more catches per hour, Luck of the Sea makes each catch more likely to be treasure. Together they roughly multiply. Add Unbreaking and Mending and the rod lasts forever; our best enchantments guide has the full list.

The open water rule

This is the part almost every beginner gets wrong. Treasure can only be caught if the bobber is in open water:

  • A 5 by 4 by 5 box around the bobber: 2 blocks out on every side, 2 above and 2 below the surface.
  • Each horizontal layer of that box must be only water source blocks (or non-solid waterlogged blocks), or only air (lily pads allowed).
  • Flowing water and blocks inside the area break it. Bubble columns can too.

In practice: fish from the middle of a lake or the sea, not a 1 block wide channel or a little pond with plants in it. If you build a fishing spot, make the pool at least 5 by 5 and about 3 blocks deep, since the bobber can sink a little. The game checks every tick, so if the bobber drifts next to a wall you lose the treasure chance until it moves away.

Making it faster

  • Fish in the rain. Rain on an open-sky bobber cuts the wait by about 20%.
  • Keep the sky open above the bobber. Without direct sky exposure the wait roughly doubles. Glass and carpet count as open; leaves and ice block it.
  • Every catch gives 1 to 6 XP, so a long session with Mending repairs your gear as you go.

A good fishing setup

  1. A rod with Lure III, Luck of the Sea III, Unbreaking III and Mending.
  2. A dock over open water: a lake or ocean, at least 5 by 5 and 3 deep, nothing growing under the bobber.
  3. A roof over you, not over the water, if you want shelter. The bobber needs open sky.
  4. A chest nearby to empty your inventory between sessions.

A note on AFK fishing farms: they still work in principle, but the open water rule means old designs with the bobber in a tiny enclosed pocket catch only fish and junk. Build it over real open water if treasure is the goal.

What to do with your catch

  • Name tags keep a mob from despawning and name your pets; besides fishing they only come from chests and trading.
  • Saddles are craftable now, but a free one is still welcome; our horse guide covers riding.
  • Nautilus shells (eight around a heart of the sea) make a conduit for underwater bases.
  • Enchanted books can carry anything from Mending to the spear's Lunge, which our spear guide explains.

Frequently asked questions

What are the odds of catching treasure in Minecraft?

5% of catches with an unenchanted rod. Luck of the Sea raises it to about 7.1%, 9.2% and 11.3% at levels I, II and III, as long as you fish in open water.

What is the best fishing rod enchantment?

For treasure, Luck of the Sea III. For speed, Lure III. Use both, plus Unbreaking and Mending so the rod never breaks.

Can you get Mending from fishing?

Yes. Treasure enchanted books, bows and rods are enchanted at level 22 to 30 and can include Mending. It is one of the few renewable ways to find Mending without trading.

Why am I not catching any treasure when fishing?

The bobber is probably not in open water. Treasure needs a 5 by 4 by 5 area of water or air around the bobber with no other blocks or flowing water, so fish in a lake or the ocean rather than a small pond.

Does rain make fishing faster in Minecraft?

Yes. If it is raining on the bobber and the sky is open above it, the wait for a bite is about 20% shorter.

Comments

Loading...

Where to next

More on this